Yes, someone can sue you after insurance pays, depending on the circumstances. The key question is whether the payment fully satisfied the claim and whether a valid release was executed.
If your insurance pays within policy limits but the judgment or damages exceed those limits, the injured party can pursue you personally for the excess amount. New Mexico recognizes excess judgments where an insurer’s bad-faith refusal to settle within policy limits leaves the insured liable for amounts beyond coverage. The insurer may be liable for the entire judgment including the excess if it violated its duty of good faith by refusing a reasonable settlement offer within policy limits.
However, if the injured party accepts a settlement payment and signs a valid release, that release generally bars further claims. A release is a complete defense to subsequent suits arising from the same injury. But a release can be set aside if it was procured by fraud, artifice, or overreaching by the insurer’s agent. New Mexico’s Release Act also requires releases of bodily injury claims to be notarized; an unnotarized release is invalid and does not bar additional recovery. Additionally, if you settle with an injured party without your insurer’s written consent, you may violate a consent-to-settle provision in your policy and lose coverage for underinsured motorist benefits or other protections
In short, insurance payment alone doesn’t automatically prevent a lawsuit. What matters is whether the payment covered the full amount owed and whether any settlement included a valid, enforceable release.

