In New Mexico, an insurance bad faith “limits letter” (also called a policy limits demand letter) is a formal written demand sent to a liability insurer — typically by a claimant or the insured — demanding that the insurer settle a claim within the policy limits by a specified deadline. The failure of an insurer to respond appropriately to such a letter can expose it to liability for any judgment in excess of those policy limits.

A bad faith limits letter is a written settlement demand directed at an insurer, offering to resolve a claim for an amount at or within the policy limits, and setting a deadline for acceptance. In Dydek v. Dydek, the court noted a demand letter from a claimant’s attorney seeking “$100K BI limits within (ten) days from date of the letter” and enclosing documentation of medical specials — a classic example of a policy limits demand letter. The insurer’s response (or failure to respond) to such a letter is central to whether it acted in good faith.

New Mexico law imposes a duty on insurers to give equal consideration to the interests of the insured when evaluating settlement demands. An insurer’s failure to conduct a competent investigation of the claim and to honestly and fairly balance its own interests and the interests of the insured in rejecting a settlement offer within policy limits constitutes bad faith. Even where the insurer’s investigation was both competent and timely, the insurer is nevertheless liable for bad faith when its refusal to settle within policy limits is based on a dishonest judgment.

When there is a great risk of recovery beyond insurance policy limits so that the most reasonable manner of disposing of the claim is a settlement which can be made within those limits, consideration in good faith of the insured’s interest requires the insurer to settle the claim. Should an insurer, in violation of its duty of good faith, refuse to accept a reasonable settlement offer within policy limits, it will be liable for the entire judgment against the insured, including the amount in excess of policy limits.

New Mexico’s Insurance Code expressly prohibits unfair claims practices. Under N.M. Stat. Ann. § 59A-16-20(E), it is an unfair and deceptive practice for an insurer to fail to attempt in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair, and equitable settlements of an insured’s claims in which liability has become reasonably clear. The statute also prohibits failing to promptly provide an insured a reasonable explanation of the basis relied on in the policy for denial of a claim or for the offer of a compromise settlement.

If an insurer’s decision not to settle is made in bad faith, the insurer may be held liable for the judgment against its insured in excess of policy limits. New Mexico courts will not permit insurers to profit by their own wrongs when they unreasonably refuse to settle within policy limits. Bad faith claims may also be based on conduct separate from a refusal to pay, such as an excessive or unnecessarily invasive claims investigation.

In summary, a bad faith limits letter in New Mexico is a demand that triggers the insurer’s heightened duty to act honestly and in good faith, and an insurer’s failure to timely and reasonably respond to such a demand can result in liability far exceeding the policy’s stated coverage limits.

An insurance bad faith letter typically refers to correspondence from an insured or their counsel addressing the insurer’s alleged wrongful conduct in handling, denying, delaying, or improperly investigating a claim. Bad faith involves the insurer’s breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing inherent in insurance contracts, mandating reasonable efforts to effectuate prompt, fair, and equitable settlements once liability is reasonably clear. Bad faith claims arise when denial or delay of payment lacks a reasonable or proper cause or when investigatory or claims-handling practices are reckless, fraudulent, or in conscious disregard of the insured’s interests. Mere negligence or mistake is insufficient to establish bad faith; rather, there must be evidence of dishonesty, intentional wrongdoing, or outrageous conduct by the insurer. The bad faith cause of action is a tort distinct from breach of contract and is aimed at compensating insureds for damages beyond policy benefits, including emotional distress and punitive damages in some instances. Insureds commonly use bad faith letters to formally notify insurers of perceived violations prior to litigation, often demanding reconsideration or settlement to avoid further claims.

Such a letter may allege unreasonable denial of benefits, failure to investigate adequately, or improper claims handling. These letters serve as a procedural tool highlighting the insurer’s alleged breach and the insured’s intent to pursue remedies available under tort law while delineating the factual and legal basis for bad faith.