In New Mexico, an injured third party generally cannot bring a common-law bad-faith claim against the tortfeasor’s insurer, but may bring a statutory unfair-claims-practices claim in defined circumstances. The statutory route is subject to important limits, including a prior judicial determination of the insured’s fault and a distinction between compulsory automobile coverage and nonmandatory excess coverage.

New Mexico’s Insurance Code identifies as an unfair claims practice an insurer’s failure to attempt in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair, and equitable settlements of an insured’s claims when liability has become reasonably clear, if the practice is knowingly committed or performed with sufficient frequency to indicate a general business practice. A person covered by Article 16 who suffers damages as a result of a violation may bring an action to recover actual damages; the court may award attorney fees in the circumstances specified by the statute.

In Hovet v. Allstate Insurance Co., an automobile-accident victim sued the liability insurer for bad-faith refusal to settle, and the New Mexico Supreme Court recognized a statutory third-party action based on unfair settlement practices. The Court required that the claim be filed only after the underlying negligence litigation concludes and a court has determined fault in favor of the third party and against the insured. Thus, a third-party claimant cannot proceed with this statutory failure-to-settle action while the underlying liability action remains unresolved.

The required adjudication is not satisfied merely by settling the underlying claim. In King v. Allstate Insurance Co., the Court of Appeals held that a compromised settlement was different from a judicial determination of liability and did not meet the prerequisite for maintaining a third-party bad-faith failure-to-settle claim

The common-law duty to settle protects the insured, not the injured third party; the Court of Appeals held that an injured third party has no common-law right to recover from the tortfeasor’s liability insurer for bad-faith refusal to settle. The Supreme Court’s statutory recognition in Hovet supplies a distinct statutory basis for the third-party claim rather than a common-law bad-faith cause of action

The statutory cause of action also does not extend to every type of liability policy. In Jolley v. Associated Electric & Gas Insurance Services Ltd., the Supreme Court declined to extend Hovet to a third-party claimant’s claim against a nonmandatory excess-liability insurer, where state law did not require the policy. Jolley therefore limits the recognized third-party statutory claim: the Court’s holding in Hovet concerned compulsory automobile liability coverage, not nonmandatory excess coverage

In summary, New Mexico permits a statutory third-party failure-to-settle claim within the limits recognized in Hovet, but not a common-law claim, and requires a prior judicial determination of liability against the insured.

Third party bad faith claims arise when an insurer acts unreasonably in investigating, defending, or settling claims brought by a third party against its insured under a liability policy. Such claims commonly involve breach of contract, negligence, and bad faith causes of action. The gravamen of third party bad faith is whether the insurer failed to settle within policy limits when a reasonable opportunity existed, exposing the insured to excess judgments. The insurer’s duty to defend is broader and distinct from its duty to indemnify. It arises when the allegations in the underlying complaint potentially bring the claim within policy coverage, even if some claims are groundless or false. The duty to settle is derivative of the duty to defend and requires acceptance of reasonable settlement offers when facing a significant risk of an excess judgment. Failure to establish both a legal duty to settle and a reasonable opportunity to do so may doom a bad faith claim. An insurer’s denial of coverage or refusal to defend will not constitute bad faith if it is based on reasonable interpretation of policy terms, lack of coverage, or lawful reservation of rights. Bad faith claim handling claims may exist even where coverage is denied but the insurer acted unreasonably or in bad faith in processing the claim

In custodial terms, the insured owes duties to cooperate and provide timely notice, while the insurer must diligently investigate, defend, and settle claims within policy limits. Liability insurer obligations include a duty to defend, which is triggered early based on potential coverage, and a duty to indemnify, contingent on actual liability determinations. The duty to defend provides “litigation insurance” and is typically broader, encompassing defense against claims where coverage may be uncertain. Courts analyze these duties primarily on the nature of the claim and the pleadings, engaging various jurisdictional standards. The insurer’s good faith duty to deal fairly includes timely, reasonable claim handling and settlement efforts, failure of which may support a bad faith claim despite disputes over coverage.