In New Mexico, claimants have multiple avenues to pursue claims against insurance companies, including statutory claims under the Insurance Code’s Trade Practices and Frauds article, common law bad faith tort claims, and claims under the Unfair Practices Act. These overlapping remedies provide robust protections for insureds against improper insurer conduct.

The primary statutory basis for claims against insurers is found in Article 16 of the New Mexico Insurance Code, N.M. Stat. Ann. §§ 59A-16-1 to -30. The scope of Article 16 is broad, applying to insurers, fraternal benefit societies, nonprofit health care plans, health maintenance organizations, agents, brokers, solicitors, and adjusters, as well as all alien and foreign insurers delivering or issuing for delivery in New Mexico any certificate or other evidence of coverage.

N.M. Stat. Ann. § 59A-16-20 defines and prohibits specific unfair claims practices. Any of the following practices with respect to claims, by an insurer or other person, knowingly committed or performed with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice are defined as unfair and deceptive practices and are prohibited:

  • Failing to adopt and implement reasonable standards for the prompt investigation and processing of insureds’ claims arising under policies
  • Not attempting in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair and equitable settlements of an insured’s claims in which liability has become reasonably clear
  • Failing to settle an insured’s claims promptly where liability has become apparent under one portion of the policy coverage in order to influence settlement under other portions
  • Failing to promptly provide an insured a reasonable explanation of the basis relied on in the policy in relation to the facts or applicable law for denial of a claim or for the offer of a compromise settlement

Any person covered by Article 16 who has suffered damages as a result of a violation of that article by an insurer or agent is granted a right to bring an action in district court to recover actual damages. Costs shall be allowed to the prevailing party unless the court otherwise directs, and the court may award attorneys’ fees to the prevailing party if the party charged with the violation has willfully engaged in the violation. The relief provided under § 59A-16-30 is in addition to remedies otherwise available against the same conduct under the common law or other statutes of the state.

New Mexico also recognizes a tort claim for unreasonable delay, in bad faith, in making payments pursuant to an insurance contract. Under New Mexico’s Uniform Jury Instructions, an insurance policy is a contract that creates a special relationship between an insurer and insured which requires an insurer to deal fairly, reasonably, honestly, and in good faith with its insureds in all aspects of the insurance contract, and the duty requires that an insurer must not place its own interests above those of an insured. However, New Mexico does not recognize a cause of action against an insurer for negligent failure to settle — the claim must be grounded in bad faith.

Claims against insurers may also be brought under the New Mexico Unfair Practices Act, N.M. Stat. Ann. § 57-12-1 et seq., which prohibits unfair or deceptive trade practices and unconscionable trade practices in the conduct of any trade or commerce. The New Mexico Supreme Court has held that the legislature did not intend to make the Unfair Insurance Practices Act the exclusive remedy under state law for conduct prohibited in that Act, meaning causes of action may be maintained under both the Unfair Insurance Practices Act and the Unfair Trade Practices Act. This principle was confirmed in Dellaira v. Farmers Ins. Exch., where the court reversed dismissal of bad faith, Insurance Code, and Unfair Practices Act claims against an insurer’s claims administrator.

In summary, New Mexico provides insureds with layered protections against improper insurer conduct through the Insurance Code’s statutory prohibitions, a private right of action for actual damages and attorneys’ fees, a recognized common law bad faith tort, and the availability of parallel claims under the Unfair Practices Act.

Claims against insurance companies frequently involve allegations of bad faith, which generally arise from wrongful refusal to pay, unreasonable delay in payment, or improper investigation and adjustment of claims. Bad faith claims exist in both first-party coverage, where the insured claims under their own policy, and third-party contexts, involving liability insurers defending or settling claims against the insured. To establish bad faith, the insured must often demonstrate that the insurer lacked a reasonable basis for denying or delaying payment and acted with knowledge or reckless disregard of the unreasonableness of its conduct. Mere negligence or honest errors in judgment are insufficient; conscious wrongdoing or gross negligence is generally required especially for punitive damages.

Statutory frameworks also shape bad faith claims, often providing remedies where insurers fail to investigate claims promptly and fairly, or fail to communicate investigative or settlement decisions reasonably. Specific statutes, such as those modeled on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ standards or state prompt payment laws, impose duties to timely evaluate and pay benefits, and violations may give rise to statutory bad faith claims. While these principles are nationally recognized, no document explicitly addresses New Mexico law; thus, general national principles govern the treatment of such bad faith claims. Courts commonly weigh whether there was an objectively reasonable dispute or bona fide controversy regarding coverage or claim legitimacy to preclude bad faith liability.