Generally, you cannot sue your insurance company for pain and suffering damages in New Mexico. The type of damages available depends on whether you’re bringing a common-law bad faith claim or a statutory unfair claims practices claim under the Insurance Code.

For common-law bad faith claims, you can recover compensatory damages, which may include the actual financial losses caused by the insurer’s bad faith conduct. Courts have awarded compensatory damages beyond the policy benefits in bad faith cases—for example, one jury awarded $20,000 in additional compensatory damages on top of breach of contract damages for bad faith denial of a claim. However, New Mexico courts have not recognized emotional distress or pain and suffering as recoverable damages in breach of contract actions, including insurance disputes, unless the parties contemplated such damages when making the contract. Insurance contracts are not considered “peace of mind” contracts that would support emotional distress damages.

Under the statutory route—the Unfair Claims Practices Act—you’re limited to actual damages, meaning the financial losses you suffered as a result of the insurer’s violation. The statute does not authorize pain and suffering or emotional distress damages; it provides only for actual damages plus costs and attorney’s fees. Punitive damages are available in common-law bad faith cases if the insurer’s conduct was in reckless disregard for your interests, was based on dishonest judgment, or was otherwise malicious, willful, or wanton, but punitive damages are not available under the statutory Insurance Code claim.

In short, while you can sue your insurer for bad faith and recover compensatory damages for financial harm caused by the bad faith conduct, pain and suffering damages are not part of the available remedies in New Mexico insurance disputes.